logo

59 pages 1 hour read

Nancy Scheper-Hughes

Death Without Weeping

Nancy Scheper-HughesNonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 1992

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapter 10Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 10 Summary: “A Knack for Life: The Everyday Tactics of Survival”

Chapter 10 shifts from a larger socioeconomic and historical lens to refocus the narrative upon three half-sisters, Lordes, Biu, and Antoinetta. Each of these sisters has very different lives, yet lives that have particular significance for the culture of Bom Jesus and the Alto. Each of their lives says something about the shared circumstances of women, and what the author believes to be a "tactics" of survival. The author makes a pointed distinction between "strategy" and "tactics," believing that the lives of the residents of the Northeast are too chaotic and rudderless to comprise any kind of enduring strategy; the argument is that their precarious position in a struggle to secure basic necessities precludes longer-range decision-making and planning. In essence, strategy is seen as a privileged position, one of power, which the residents of the Alto lack.

Instead, the author describes the varied lifestyles of Alto residents as a "tactics"―a collection of skills, postures, and attitudes, which, in concert, comprise a "knack" for living. Although recognizable among members of a community, this "knack" for living is highly individual, and ultimately dependent on how a particular person sees oneself. For example, Antoinetta makes her way utilizing structures of patronage and favors to maneuver herself into her desired position, while Biu prizes her independence and work ethic above all else. The object of these "tactics," then, is personal, even individual, as these women and mothers develop means to deal with the economic and domestic challenges of their lives. This domestic life, as the author describes, can be complicated, if not convoluted. In the Alto, marriage is as likely to be informal as formal; common-law marriage and cohabitation are common. In this atmosphere, one's "tactics" are as much an attempt to create and sustain order, as much as to prove one's particular lifestyle or self-concept. The stake of these "tactics," of course, is reinforced with children. Frequent pregnancy and infant death prove to be the common denominator of these women's lives, yet how each woman must contrive to support their families is a testament to not only the strength of their character, but the individuality thereof.

Chapter 10 Analysis

The more intimate focus of Chapter 10 provides an illuminating and challenging perspective to life on the Alto. The personal stories enrich and complicate our understanding of life on the Alto for women in meaningful and productive ways. Additionally, these stories provide texture to certain observations and arguments in Death Without Weeping. Among these is the concept of a "tactics" of survival: that is to say, the disorder and deprivation of life prevents longer-term, abstract goal-seeking. This argument, however, often ignores these women's implicit and explicit priorities, and opportunity for open-ended reflection in what may be paradoxically described as an "exuberantly" stoical culture challenges the narratives of rural life.

That the half-sisters―Biu, Antoinetta, and Lordes―display a lucid and sophisticated capacity for reflection is not all remarkable nor noteworthy in itself. Though functionally illiterate, they are obviously empathetic, intelligent, and perceptive. Instead, what is remarkable and noteworthy is the context of such a monologue, and how its relative rarity in the community is a function of its own ethos. Biu, declaring to the author the she "won't cry" about her life, exemplifies this ethos: the deprivation and trauma of shantytown life is such that there is little space or emotional energy to be wasted on expressions of self-pity and anxiety; these only detract from one's ability to meet the needs of the day. However, as Biu specifies, this is a decision, and a painful one. Yet, it can be argued that this "tactic" represents only a smaller part of Biu's own strategy to gain autonomy, an effort frustrated by the harsh, exploitative environment but never fully extinguished. 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 59 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools