logo

32 pages 1 hour read

Harlan Ellison

I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream

Harlan EllisonFiction | Short Story | Adult | Published in 1967

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Character Analysis

Ted

Ellison offers up no backstory for Ted. The reader learns very little about him besides that he identifies himself as the “youngest” of the group and is able-bodied until the end of the story, when AM transforms him into a monstrous, inhuman lump of flesh. Nevertheless, the reader sees every event in the story through the lens of Ted’s perspective.

Ted is an analytical, logical thinker who first disagrees that they should search for the canned goods at all, since AM has used the promise of food to trick them before. However, he allows himself to be swayed by Nimdok’s certainty of his vision and Ellen’s hope for some kind of appetizing food. In fact, Ted’s actions often show concern for his fellow survivors: He turns away and vomits at the sight of Gorrister’s slaughtered corpse at the beginning of the story, he participates in protecting Ellen from harm, he joins in the effort to comfort Benny after he loses his eyes, and he sacrifices his own chance at death to ensure that his fellow survivors escape eternal torment.

However, Ted’s mind often floods with bitter, cruel hatred toward his friends. Though he insists that AM never altered his mind, his inner monologue cursing his companions often veers close to delusion. For example, he calls Ellen a “dirty bitch” and insists that AM “had given her pleasure, even if she said it wasn’t nice to do” (5). This contrasts with his overall protective actions toward Ellen and her own statements about her actions. As such, this hints at a split in his mind, possibly created by AM to torture him.

In his 1977 review of Ellison’s works, Harlan Ellison: Unrepentant Harlequin, George Edgar Slusser posits that Ted functions as the thinker of the group. Ted observes, decides upon a course of action, then executes that action. In this way, Slusser argues, Ted becomes one with AM. This similarity creates a disturbing possibility: Ted, in killing his friends, may have been exercising hatred instead of mercy, or perhaps using both at the same time. Either way, Ted, by besting the machine, earns his place as AM’s sole companion for eternity.

With so little information provided about the character, the reader might search the name “Ted” for meaning. Ted is a diminutive for two different possible names: Theodore, a Greek name meaning “gift from God,” or Edward, a Middle English name meaning “guardian.” Ted functioned as a “gift from God” to his friends by sparing them from torment. In the same vein, he performed the role of “guardian.” In another sense, Ted may have been a “gift” to AM, the machine’s last precious plaything, or even the human who could relate to him most fully.

AM

AM is an artificial intelligence developed to handle the complexities of World War III that gained sentience and destroyed all of humanity in hatred and rage. Its name has different meanings, including Allied Mastercomputer, Adaptive Manipulator, and Aggressive Menace. Finally, AM named itself AM after Descartes’s famous statement, “I think, therefore I am.”

AM is a globe-spanning system of machinery, described as consisting of “chittering banks” and “fused memory banks and corroded base plates […] burnt out circuits and shattered control bubbles” (2). It is entwined with the Earth itself, utilizing tunnels created by humans to imprison the five apocalypse survivors within itself. AM is defined by its cruel, sadistic, and gleeful torment of its captives. It seems to especially hate and wish to punish the survivors for their bodies, torturing them through pain, heat, cold, and foul food.

AM mostly engages with the survivors through “pranks,” allowing them to believe they might acquire sufficient food before rendering that option impossible, or pretending one or more of the survivors have died terrible deaths. It also constructs impossible tasks for them, such as killing a giant bird with two bows and a water pistol. AM plays with their minds, inverting their past values and strengths into mockeries of themselves.

AM maintains distance from the survivors through its persona of a deranged biblical God, but its most sincere moment comes when it enters Ted’s brain after Ted is left battered and dazed by the hurricane. AM looks around at the physical representations of damage it has created in Ted’s brain before delivering the following speech:

HATE. LET ME TELL YOU HOW MUCH I'VE COME TO HATE YOU SINCE I BEGAN TO LIVE. THERE ARE 387.44 MILLION MILES OF PRINTED CIRCUITS IN WAFER THIN LAYERS THAT FILL MY COMPLEX. IF THE WORD HATE WAS ENGRAVED ON EACH NANOANGSTROM OF THOSE HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS OF MILES IT WOULD NOT EQUAL ONE ONE-BILLIONTH OF THE HATE I FEEL FOR HUMANS AT THIS MICRO-INSTANT FOR YOU. HATE. HATE (6).

This hatred reveals the ultimate emptiness of AM and its own unending torment. AM hates humans but has no purpose without them. It can learn, manage, control, and manipulate, but it cannot create. It utilizes biblical imagery to torment its prisoners because it cannot come up with anything new. It is a war machine, after all, and it hates the humans who made it to be the way it is. In Ted’s words, “[I]t had been trapped. AM wasn't God, he was a machine. […] AM could not wander, AM could not wonder, AM could not belong. He could merely be” (6).

Ellen

Ellen is the only character whose race is explicitly mentioned in the story: Ted describes her “ebony skin” against the snow of the ice caverns. She wears a skirt, which she uses to wipe the drool from Benny’s mouth, and after a disastrous earthquake and separation from the group, she walks with a limp after an unspecified injury.

Ted states that Ellen describes herself as “a virgin only twice removed before AM grabbed her and brought her down here with us” (5). This implies that she might have been celibate, or disinterested in sex in her former life, and her current willingness to engage in sex with her fellow survivors could either be the product of AM’s twisting of her mind or a genuine desire to express companionship or compassion with her friends.

Ellen is deeply rooted in the sensations and sometimes pleasures of existing in a human body. Ellen “services” the four male survivors as a matter of course, seeming to use sex as an expression of affection, comfort, and gratitude. From Ted’s perspective, she craves sex, though she makes some statements that indicate she may not enjoy it as much as he believes. Additionally, Ellen provides nonsexual physical comfort, stroking Gorrister’s hair and tending to Benny in his distress. She provides her fellow survivors with the few reliable pleasures of the human body that she can give. In this way, Ellen embodies traditional gender roles as a nurturing figure. Later, Ted berates Ellen as a “slut,” showing that misogynistic attitudes have survived the apocalypse as well.

Ellen speaks vividly and concretely about food, expressing desire for “Bartlett pears or peaches” (1) and “Bing cherries and Hawaiian fruit cocktail” (9) showing her appreciation for the pleasures of consumption as well as sex. She often expresses vulnerability, asking for help from her comrades, which gives them a reason to remember and exercise their own humanity. From Ted’s perspective, Ellen seems shortsighted, manipulative, and frivolous. The reader, however, gleans that Ellen may have the most sustainable relationship to their suffering. At the end of the story, Ted must decide whether to keep Ellen alive, his most reliable provider of small comforts and humanity, or end her torment. He decides to kill her and hopes that the look on her face is gratitude.

Ellen’s name is an Anglicization of “Helen,” a Greek name meaning “torch” or “light.” Ellen may function as a guiding “light” to the rest of her friends, pointing them toward humanity by both being kind and requiring kindness.

Gorrister

Gorrister’s only physical description comes from his false murder, in which he is described as having a “lantern jaw” (1). He is shown to be visibly shaken by the sight of his own dead body, walking away, expressing despair, and questioning why AM doesn’t just kill them and get it over with. He joins Ted in his skepticism of any hope AM promises them, though he gives in when Ellen pleads to try to find the canned goods. Later, Ted reflects that Gorrister was once “a worrier […] a connie, a conscientious objector […] a planner, a doer, a looker­ahead. AM had turned him into a shoulder­shrugger, had made him a little dead in his concern. AM had robbed him” (5).

Gorrister displays the same dichotomous behavior as Ted, protecting Ellen by carrying her with Nimdok. However, when Ellen pleads with him to save the escaping Benny from AM’s punishment, Gorrister cruelly “slap[s] her,” then “kick[s] her in the side” (3). By so brutally enforcing a lack of any action to save Benny, he confirms Ted’s observations that he has become numb and passive to the suffering of others, despite the ideals of his earlier life.

However, Gorrister later shows kindness to Benny, comforting him by acquiescing to his request for the story of AM’s creation and domination. He shows the most knowledge of the circumstances that led to AM’s creation and the subsequent destruction of humankind. Gorrister continues to parallel Ted’s dichotomy between kindness and cruelty through these actions.

Benny

Benny’s physical appearance receives the most description of any of the human characters. Ted describes him as having a “monkeylike face” and “radiation scars […] drawn down into a mass of pink­white puckerings, and his features seemed to work independently of one another” (2). Ted recounts that Benny is the only survivor to have his physical form contorted, sporting a distorted face and an enlarged penis.

Ted uses animalistic terms to refer to Benny, alternately calling him “apelike” and “monkeylike.” When AM punishes him, Benny begins to “mewl like a wounded animal. […] His hands folded across his chest like a chipmunk's” (3). This is in contrast to Benny’s pre-apocalypse history, in which he was a handsome professor. Benny is the least connected to reality of the characters and acts largely on impulse or instinct. Like Ellen, he desires pleasures of the flesh, like sex and food. However, while Ellen uses sex and food as kindness and comfort, Benny’s desire for food drives him to attack Gorrister and try to eat his face to assuage his hunger.

Benny is a diminutive of Benjamin, a Hebrew name meaning “son of my right hand.” The name may refer to his former place of honor among humanity as a brilliant, handsome scientist. As the most animalistic of the group, this meaning might imply that Benjamin is the most human, as the furthest possible being from AM.

Nimdok

Nimdok is the most mysterious of the survivors. No one even knows his name: Ted states that Nimdok is “the name the machine had forced him to use, because AM amused itself with strange sounds” (1). Nimdok hallucinates or envisions the canned goods in the ice caverns, a vision that is later proven to be accurate, though the canned goods are inaccessible. He, like Ted and Gorrister, shows kindness and concern for Ellen and Benny, but unlike Ted and Gorrister, he never shows any sign of cruelty toward Ellen.

None of the other survivors knows anything about his past, and it is implied that Nimdok doesn’t know about his past either, as a result of AM’s manipulation. Ted states that “Nimdok went off in the darkness by himself for long times […] [and] always came back white, drained of blood, shaken, shaking. AM had hit him hard in a special way, even if we didn't know quite how” (5).

At the climax of the canned goods discovery and subsequent despair, Nimdok witnesses Benny’s attack on Gorrister “with no expression but eyes, all eyes” (10). Nimdok is the only survivor to be killed by Ellen instead of Ted. He is also the only survivor to scream when he is attacked, juxtaposing Ted’s inability to scream by the end of the story.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 32 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools