logo

52 pages 1 hour read

Eva Ibbotson

Journey to the River Sea

Eva IbbotsonFiction | Novel | Middle Grade | Published in 2001

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

Fear of the Unknown

Content Warning: This section of the guide discusses the source text’s use of outdated and offensive terms to discuss Indigenous cultures and its portrayal of colonial stereotypes of Indigenous people.

The novel portrays the fear of the unknown as a barrier to exploration and connection. Characters are either aligned or at odds with each other based on their different interactions and reactions to their environment, the people around them, and their personal growth. Maia’s boarding school classmates, teachers, and the Carter family all represent a fear-dominated perspective that keeps them isolated and static. The girls at her school are portrayed as fearful and childish and remain unchanged throughout the story. For example, they become anxious at Maia’s departure, and in this scene, Maia’s brave willingness to face the unknown gives her a stance of maturity by comparison. When she returns to the school after her adventures, Maia has grown, but the school and its pupils remain the same. Maia humorously reflects that the geography teacher is probably teaching the same lesson as when she left. When she shares her story, the other girls are unable to “take it in” (186) and therefore miss out on the rich experiences that have transformed Maia.

The Carters’ fear of the unknown is depicted as an isolating and inhibiting force in their lives, but also as a sinister quality. This dynamic is foreshadowed by Maia’s reflection that “Fear is the cause of all evil” (9). Accordingly, the Carters react with hostility to the unfamiliar environment of the Amazon, symbolized by Mrs. Carter’s obsession with using toxic chemicals to kill insects. The sensory imagery used to describe Mrs. Carter’s violent bug-killing routines highlights her aggressive nature, for as the narrative states, she uses a “flit-gun” for “squirting every nook and cranny with insect killer” and a broom to “thump and bang on the ceiling to get rid of possible spiders” (33). Her daughters inherit their parents’ aggression and inability to connect with others; this aggression is evident quite early in the novel, for Gwendolyn nastily pinches Maia’s skin when she shakes her hand for the first time. The twins clearly fear Maia, viewing her talent for the piano, her good looks, and her relationships with the servants as a threat to themselves; as a result, they scheme to get rid of her and treat her maliciously. Their father’s fear manifests itself through his brutality and exploitative behavior that leads to bankruptcy and ruin. While many other European families are successful at rubber planting, Mr. Carter’s farm is unproductive and fails because of his ruthless treatment and violent punishments of the workers, so that “far from making his fortune, he was getting poorer and poorer” (32). The Carters’ state of incarceration and servitude at the end of the novel can easily be interpreted as poetic justice for their crimes. Unwilling to face their fear of an unfamiliar environment or foreign people, the Carters morally deteriorate and become villains.

Human Greed and Exploitation

The novel explores the role of human greed and exploitation in the Amazon through its historical setting of the story at a time of booming colonial immigration and exploration in Brazil. Many of the characters in the book, such as Sergei and the Keminsky family, prosper from their willful exploitation of the Amazon’s natural resources and cheap labor force, which the novel attributes to their relationship with their workers. The Indigenous Brazilians in the novel are portrayed either as victims of exploitation (such as when Mr. Carter steals Tapuri land and destroys their sacred longhouse), or else they act as cooperative helpers to the colonizers. The deeper social undercurrents become apparent, for example, when Mrs. Minton attempts to shield Finn from the truth of imperial violence: the unavoidable fact that “tribes had been wiped out by illness, or fighting, or been kidnapped” (126). This mention creates an oblique awareness of the greater history of exploitation that permeates the setting of the novel. Likewise, the servants who live at the back of the Carters’ property are treated poorly but feel compelled to remain because of circumstance or poverty; the character of Conchita is a prime example, for she stays “because she ha[s] a crippled brother to support in Manaus” (105). Thus, despite the fact that Journey to the River Sea is intended to be a children’s novel, the author does not ignore the darker aspects of the time in which the story is set.

The novel also portrays colonizers and Indigenous people working in cooperation with one another as well as engaging in conflict. The novel thus uses various subplots to explore exploitative power dynamics and the issue of cultural insensitivity. For example, when Trapwood and Low go to the tribal village without “any of the presents one usually brings when visiting a tribe—fishhooks, and knives and cooking pots” (77), the tribespeople demonstrate their own strong sense of agency by punishing the investigators in their own way; in exchange for Trapwood and Low’s lack of respect, the villagers lie to them about the whereabouts of their quarry. Similarly, the Carters’ servants deceive the family about their level of fluency in English, acting sullen inside the bungalow and lively outside it. In contrast with the Carters, Maia, Finn, and Bernard Taverner are protected by the Brazilian people, who are portrayed as generous helpers. For example, Furo warns Finn when the inspectors are coming for Clovis and ferries Maia secretly between the Carters’ house and Finn’s hut. Likewise, when Finn leaves Maia, he asks Furo to protect her. Colonel De Silva also asks the local tribes to protect Finn because of their loyalty to his father, who used to spend a lot of time in the jungle with the local Indigenous people. These various relationships reflect the nuances of cooperation versus exploitation that exist in a colonialist setting.

Romantic Portrayals of Wilderness Exploration

The novel captures the excitement and mythical status of the Amazon and its potential for scientific and natural discovery through its setting and characters. The wild jungle of the Amazon is described romantically in lavish detail as both a fearsome and awe-inspiring place that comes alive in the imagination of Maia and her boarding school peers, who fantasize about creatures like alligators, jaguars, mosquitoes, leeches, and piranhas. Maia reads about “the maze of rivers,” the “thousand plants and animals that had never been seen before,” and “the wisdom of the [Indigenous people] who could cure sickness and wounds that no one in Europe understood” (11). The Amazon is therefore depicted as a place of great mystery and hidden discoveries, reflecting the popular imagination of its historical setting.

Both Finn’s late naturalist father Bernard Taverner and his friend Professor Glastonberry, the latter of whom runs the Manaus Natural History Museum, add to the novel’s portrayal of the value of natural exploration and entrepreneurship. Bernard dies in a tragic canoeing accident while out looking “for the blue waterlily whose leaves were used as a painkiller” (69). The romanticized image of a wilderness explorer facing danger on a scientific adventure is upheld and idealized by the other main characters, who long to pursue adventures in the wilderness themselves. Even secondary characters profess their love of the idea of adventure, for Professor Glastonberry admires his friend Carruthers, who died looking for a mythic giant sloth, and Miss Minton reflects that dying on an adventure is “better than dying in a hospital with strangers” (143). She also encourages Professor Glastonberry to search for the missing rib piece of the museum’s giant sloth skeleton, and her belief that “anyone who can walk can go on expeditions” (93) encapsulates her adventurous spirit and leads her to boldly follow Maia and Finn up the river on their trip to the Xanti tribe.

The Value of Friendship

The value of friendship and chosen family for personal growth and healing is demonstrated in the novel through the transformation of its characters as they grow in relationship to each other. The three main characters—Maia, Finn, and Clovis—are all orphans grieving the loss of their parents and learning how to survive on their own. Each of them transforms and learns how to trust in each other and help each other fulfill their dreams.

For Maia, her dream is to have a home and no longer be alone. She is desperate for a sense of belonging, and this desire is shown in her detailed daydreams of what her life will be like in the Amazon with her adopted sisters. Despite the fact that the letter she receives from the self-centered twins is only two lines long, she becomes obsessed with the idea of them. As the narrative states, “She imagined them getting ready for bed, brushing each other’s hair, and lying in a hammock with a basket full of kittens on their laps, or picking flowers for the house” (22). When she eventually realizes that they are bullies who have no interest in befriending her, she blames herself and tries harder to please them, at least until her newfound friendship with Finn and Sergei gives her a new perspective on the twins’ cruel nature. In contrast, when she is aboard Finn’s ship, she loses her fear of "the nastiness of the twins” and feels as if “she wouldn’t be scared of anything if she was with Finn” (166).

Finn’s dream is to reconnect with his mother’s people, a journey that is also a tribute to his father’s wish for him not to live the stuffy life of an aristocrat. Finn’s fear of returning to the Taverner family is demonstrated by his comparison of Westwood to a prison where “they lock you up as soon as you’re born” (73). Finn finds happiness in the pursuit of adventure, symbolized through his care for and restoration of the Arabella, his father’s boat. Even boat itself evokes a spirit of adventure, for it is named after Miss Minton, who encouraged Bernard to pursue his dreams. When Finn embarks on his journey with Maia in the boat, they are metaphorically carried by the spirit of his father into the Amazon, and to his mother’s home.

Clovis’s main wish is to be reunited with his foster mother and the comforts of his childhood English home. His warmth and regard for Maia and Miss Minton, who “always made him feel safe” (49) leads him on his quest to help Finn, which requires courage. His performance for the investigators reveals his moment of transformation, as he becomes “the golden-haired youth who had appeared at the top of the cellar steps. The boy’s breeding showed in every movement; he was an undoubted and true aristocrat” (122). His ability to rise to the occasion and save his friends changes the trajectory of his life from poverty and suffering to wealth and comfort.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 52 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools