Some of Us Had Been Threatening Our Friend Colby

Evaluate the dynamics of the group in the story. How do their interactions and group decisions reflect societal norms and the concept of conformity?

Explore the character of Colby. Despite being the central figure, he is largely passive. How does his character contribute to the story’s theme of Dehumanization and the Erosion of Individuality?

The story contains minimal descriptions of the characters. How does Barthelme’s approach to characterization affect the story? How does the lack of personal detail contribute to the themes and mood of the story?

Barthelme’s story uses a first-person plural perspective (“we”). How does this narrative choice influence the reader’s understanding and engagement with the story? What effects does it have on the story’s themes?

Discuss the story’s title. How does it set expectations for the reader, and in what ways does the story fulfill or subvert these expectations?

The narrative of “Some of Us Had Been Threatening Our Friend Colby” is devoid of explicit moral judgment. Explore this aspect and discuss its implications. How does it amplify the story’s critique of society?

The group plans Colby’s execution with an oddly casual and organized approach. Analyze this attitude and discuss its impact on the story’s critique of groupthink and desensitization to violence.

Examine Barthelme’s use of humor in the story. How does the darkly comedic tone serve the story’s broader themes and message?