logo

65 pages 2 hours read

Winona Guo, Priya Vulchi

Tell Me Who You Are: Sharing Our Stories of Race, Culture, & Identity

Winona Guo, Priya VulchiNonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 2021

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapter 8Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 8 Summary: “Diversity Is Not the Goal”

The introduction to this chapter begins with the authors’ experiences in Council Bluffs, Iowa, which is 92.6% white. When they seek interviewees, no one wants to discuss race. Three months later in New York City, interviewees remark on the city's diversity and equality, even though it is still largely segregated. The authors argue that this illustrates the interviewees’ indifference to real diversity, which means equity, not just equality or integration. A student named Kyle explains equity this way: “Equality is a truck showing up and giving out only size 8 Nikes. Equity is a truck that shows up and has a size shoe that fits everybody. That way, everyone can walk around” (251).

In the first of the 10 interviews in the chapter, Aaron G. describes how race is a social construct that becomes internalized and creates inequities. He has faced racial and religious discrimination as a Black man who practices the Baha’i religion; he grew up in a small town in Colorado where swastikas and “the n-word” were prevalent. He joined Black Lives Matter in 2014 and outlines a path for healing from racism: healing from one’s personal trauma, relational work with others, and addressing the systems at work. A footnote describes the “mark of Cain,” which a Mormon accused him of having because he is Black.

Isabella, who is Hispanic, looks at equity from the perspective of belonging. Both of her parents have graduate degrees and she herself attended boarding school, but she was seen as a token person of color there (footnotes address tokenization and how society allows white people to feel they belong anywhere). She also experienced racism during a gap year in Colombia while having to translate for white women.

Inequities exist in continued segregation in schools and neighborhoods. Katja, who is white, adopted two children from Ethiopia, including her son Gadisa. She describes the segregated neighborhoods in Omaha, Nebraska, and how she teaches at a majority Black school, which illustrates the lack of equity in the city. A group of students from Central High School in Little Rock, Arkansas, note that though the high school integrated in 1957 (also explained in a footnote), students still group together by race. They detail how their different races lead to different experiences. Footnotes consider the concept of reverse racism, the issue of redlining, and the dearth of Black teachers in elementary schools.

Angela, a Latina representative at the Utah House of Representatives, aims to increase equity for women and women of color and engage them in politics. She describes the racism she has experienced as well as the privilege she had when getting a job in the mayor’s office due to her connections. A footnote addresses how white applicants usually benefit the most from the help of networks. Another footnote addresses the flawed concept of pulling oneself up by the bootstraps.

In a group interview, Eric, Josiah, and Galen, white men from Whitefish, Montana, explain that the town lacks diversity but say they would still see everyone as equal if their school was more diverse. Footnotes define the terms “nonracist” versus “antiracist” and describe Richard Spencer, a white supremacist who lives in Whitefish.

Addressing food and land equity, Patience K., a multiracial woman whose father is from the Congo and whose mother has Mexican and white heritage, highlights the link between poverty and race. Footnotes explain food deserts, health inequalities and lack of insurance among people of color, and land ownership by Black families after the Civil War.

Diversity can involve representation: Sione notes the underrepresentation and misrepresentation of Pacific Islander populations in the media and his goal of being a role model. A footnote details the number of Pacific Islander people with bachelor’s degrees.

Matt, who is white, describes his grandparents’ racism. In contrast, he strives for equity in education, community work, and housing at Pine Ridge Reservation in South Dakota (described in a footnote). He notes how systemic racism places power in the hands of white men and considers the difficulty of reclaiming that power for good ends.

Jennifer M. and Felice describe their interracial friendship, how they support each other on racial issues, and how people frequently ask them about race because of their friendship. A footnote discusses the term “cracker,” which Jennifer was once called by a Black man.

Chapter 8 Analysis

Chapter 8 argues that a focus on diversity and equality prioritizes treating all people the same and ignores the existence of inequities. It therefore advocates for equity, which acknowledges that people do not begin at the same starting point. Generations of racism, along with institutions that inhibit people of color’s access to resources and opportunities, contribute to inequitable outcomes for people of color. This is one reason why, the book argues, everyone must focus on Acknowledging Systemic Inequities and Privilege: Failing to do so merely compounds the problems of the “equality” framework.

Aaron G.’s description further explains how race creates inequities. Even though race is a social construct rather than a biological fact, it becomes real to those who experience racial inequities, as well as to those who benefit from them; those inequities become even deeper and even more entrenched across generations. This is an idea that many experts on race and racism have articulated. Ibram Kendi, for example, states, “We are what we see ourselves as, whether what we see exists or not. We are what people see us as, whether what they see exists or not. What people see in themselves and others has meaning [...] even if what they are seeing is an illusion” (Kendi, Ibram X. How to Be an Antiracist. One World, 2019).

For those with privilege, however, it can be easy to overlook the influence of segregation and other forms of systemic oppression on inequities. Eric, Josiah, and Galen offer an example. They remark that they would still see everyone as equal if their majority white school were more diverse: “It’s easy to say, since we’re all generally White, but I still think that even if we had more diversity in our school, we would still treat people the same” (270). However, Eric adds an anecdote about a Black student who won an award as proof: “I think it shows we have a lot of respect in Whitefish for different cultures” (270-71). This is a form of tokenization, illustrating how people who lack the equity framework can feel like including one person of color in a group constitutes diversity. Because they are not exposed to racism and do not experience it, the group lacks awareness of racism’s very existence—particularly the racist policies that buttress inequity in the US.

Although some white people do recognize systemic racism, their actions may be limited to superficial efforts, as Matt describes: “[A] lot of what folks, especially White moderates and White progressives, look for: a check box at some point in life to say, ‘Look at me, showing compassion! Look at me caring about race!’” (279). These small efforts are not enough; change requires daily work, but because many white people are unaware of the true reach of systemic racism, they view minor efforts as more meaningful than they in fact are.

An equity framework also has implications for the way people think about poverty, as Patience K. attests, “Wealth was able to be produced by having land, being able to cultivate that land with free labor, turning it into industry. If you had no land, as many people of color didn’t, you had no means to build wealth over generations and generations. You have cycles of poverty” (273-74). Because poverty is often intergenerational, approaches aimed at “equality” often fail to address it. What’s more, poverty often intersects with other forms of oppression, demanding an even more nuanced recognition of the various factors that may be holding people back.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 65 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools