50 pages • 1 hour read
Janice Y. K. LeeA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Mercy sits alone at a bar. She met a college acquaintance for lunch but ended it early when it became awkward and the woman realized that Mercy could not help her with job connections. In the bar, she runs into Charlie Leung, a young Chinese man she knew at Columbia.
Afterward, David Starr, Hilary’s husband, approaches her. Though she knows that any man in a bar at three o’clock in the afternoon is probably up to no good, she allows him to buy her a drink. They get drunk and flirt all afternoon, and she tells him the name of a restaurant she frequents.
Margaret finishes her bath and eats a sandwich. She returns home to prepare for a dinner party that evening at Hilary and David’s house. She knew Hilary when they were children in California and remembers her as a chubby girl with an overbearing mother who lost a lot of weight one summer. Though Margaret didn’t admire Hilary’s determination, she recognized that she was “formidable.” They have a casual friendship as adults, sparked by Hilary reaching out after G disappeared.
At dinner, she and Clarke make small talk. They dislike David, who is often drunk, but the other party guests are pleasant enough. Margaret is grateful that she and Clarke still love one another since divorce is common among couples who lose a child.
Hilary lies in bed after the party, thinking about how boring it was. She feels sorry for Margaret and Clarke because of their loss. She is also angry because David left after the party to go out again, claiming he had plans with a friend. Hilary had to pretend that she knew about the plans and agreed to them and is now resentful and embarrassed. She knows that he is probably being unfaithful, and that is what Olivia wanted to tell her.
She thinks about other marriages that ended here. It is common for expat men to divorce their wives or be unfaithful. She remembers a friend, Tammy, whose husband started a second family with a young Chinese woman on the mainland. He divorced Tammy and refused to leave his new family. Everyone gossiped, and Tammy lost her social standing. Tammy weathered the storm and now seems happier, though she is no longer an immaculately coiffed housewife. Hilary thinks that Tammy might have the right idea—to live one’s life and stop caring about what the gossips say.
Mercy wakes in her room, where David is sleeping in her bed. They hooked up after he met her at the restaurant, and now she worries that he will be regretful or rude. She thinks about her experiences with the Reade family and thinks of herself as a careless girl with bad luck. She remembers that after G’s disappearance, the Korean police were exasperated with her Korean language skills. She left the Reades and stayed at a cheap motel for a few days before going home on her own, and she has not seen them since. She feels unable to confide in anyone, especially her mother.
David awakens, smiles at her, and asks what they should eat for breakfast.
Margaret and Clarke take their children on a trip to Thailand. It is their first vacation without G, and Margaret is reluctant to go. However, the beach is gorgeous, and Daisy and Philip are excited. The only hitch occurs at the airport when they are not allowed to board because their party is incomplete. Margaret confesses that she let their travel agent buy a ticket for G because she didn’t know how to explain what happened to her. Clarke is upset, telling her that he understands how she feels but that she is damaging her living children.
They reconcile at the resort, but Margaret is lost in her thoughts about the initial weeks of G’s disappearance. She lived in Seoul for months, allowing Clarke and the children to return to Hong Kong without her. She went to the police station daily and befriended the officers, buying them food and coffee. She also spent her days chasing down useless leads, like the exact pair of pants G was wearing. Eventually, she came home, realizing that Daisy and Philip needed her.
Hilary wakes up feeling awful. She takes some Advil and sends her driver to pick up her mother from the airport—she is visiting from California. She goes back to sleep and finds that David is still not home when she wakes from her nap. She worries about how to explain this to her mother because she does not want to discuss her marital problems with her.
While waiting for her mother to arrive, she logs onto an expat forum, where she spends a lot of time. She uses the pseudonym HappyGal and pretends to be a different person, reveling in the anonymity. Today, she is horrified to see that someone posted about her and Julian, criticizing her for treating Julian as something she is “‘trying out,’ like a ball gown she can return” (136). She unravels, worrying about the adoption, her reputation, her marriage, and her mother’s imminent arrival.
David takes Mercy to breakfast and complains about his marriage, confiding that he feels trapped by Hilary and her sadness. Afterward, he tries to get Mercy to open up. She tells him that she is not an “escape hatch” or an excuse for his bad behavior that he can blame later. Startled, he tells her that he knows that. She tells him that now, they can begin having a real conversation.
In Thailand, Margaret gets a massage while her children play on the beach with Clarke. She runs into Frannie, another expat, and the two families have dinner together. Margaret thinks how artificial the environment here is, where expats are treated like royalty by the local staff. After dinner, the children release floating lanterns over the ocean. Daisy excitedly tells Margaret that she made a wish, and Margaret feels devastated that G is not there with them.
While her mother takes a shower, Hilary waits for word from David. He finally emails to tell her that he is taking some time for himself and doesn’t know when he will be back. He also tells her that he will not make it home in time to accompany Hilary and her mother on their planned trip to Bangkok. Hilary worries about what to tell her mother but also feels a sudden sense of relief that the marriage is ending.
In Part 3, the narrative threads begin to converge with both Margaret and Mercy connecting with Hilary. Margaret attends Hilary’s party in the novel’s present and was also a childhood friend of hers. This allows Lee to characterize Hilary (not altogether flatteringly) through Margaret’s eyes. Though Margaret doesn’t “admire” Hilary’s childhood discipline, “the disconcerting sense never left her that Hilary was a deeply formidable person, one who would win over her genetics […] and whatever else stood in her way and never look back” (93). As a child, Hilary’s will is displayed through her intense diet regimen. As an adult, she is a more passive person, observing her life rather than experiencing it directly.
The most passion Hilary displays in this section is anger at David for staying out late and embarrassing her at the party. This rage foreshadows her eventual crisis and the fact that she will finally take control of her life back. Hilary’s rage also leads her to reflect on patriarchal gender roles that are present in the expat community. Many husbands abandon their wives for younger women or start new families, while options are much more limited for women. Hilary thinks about how this bad behavior is universally excused by everyone and goes “unpunished”—nothing bad befalls these men, while their ex-wives often must take menial jobs or move back home. Hilary does not have this concern since she is independently wealthy, but David seems to chafe at his wife’s freedom. He rants to Mercy: “I work all the time, and all she does is sit around and mope. You know, her family’s rich, and she thinks that entitles her to bitch and be sad all day” (139). Though Hilary is not yet aware of David’s attitude about her family, she subconsciously picks up on it and is constantly foreshadowing their separation.
In this section, Mercy is also part of David’s “bad behavior,” though she knows that he is married. Thematically, she is still on The Search for Identity and Belonging. Reeling from the trauma of losing G, she is trying to find a way to live. Her friends are unsympathetic, and it becomes clear that she is alone in Hong Kong without a support network. One of them chastises her for not having a steady job, hinting that it is “unseemly” that Mercy still takes trips. Mercy realizes that “[she] thinks she is like her friends, and they think she is different. It was not so apparent in college, but now in postcollege life, in real life, it is obvious that they think she is different” (90). This epiphany echoes the warning in the fortune teller’s pamphlet, which says that Mercy is a crow who cannot fly among eagles. She worries that the prophecy is true and that she “is indeed the unluckiest girl in the world” (107). To fight this despair and loneliness, Mercy loses herself in meeting men like David and passing the time in small ways. Though she knows that David is married and likely a bad choice for her, she still gives him a second chance to get to know her after he spends breakfast ranting about his wife. She also sees Charlie Leung briefly before she meets David, a former classmate who is, in many ways, a better choice for her. He is kind and closer to her in age. However, Mercy is dismissive of him, calling him “a bit FOB—fresh off the boat” and “nerdy” (85). Ironically, she judges Charlie in the same way that her friends judge her, which she finds isolating. At this juncture, Mercy does not recognize the ways that she is obstructing her own happiness.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features: